Pacifica Beauty, Eye Love Liquid Charcoal Eyeliner, Black, No-Skip, Smudge-Proof, Matte Finish, Precise Application, Pen Tip, Vegan, Cruelty-Free

Not sure why other people are giving negative reviews. Easy to apply, very precise tip, and bold black. Easy to remove and doesn't make my eyes dry like many others. Love the ingredients and will continue to buy

I love most Pacifica products, but this is the second time I’ve bought this eyeliner and I won’t be doing a third purchase. The pigmentation is very weak and it wears off quickly. It also runs out super fast and the tip was weirdly fuzzy when I went to use it after a few days. Definitely not a good value for the price.

Easy to apply, soft look, stays on all day and is clean. Ran out pretty quickly.

Easy to apply. But it's too light not dark.

For a cleaner beauty product it works really well and doesn't leave my eyes itchy like more chemical-filled brands.