Justin's Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups, 12 Pack

My favorite treat! Way better than those other chocolate peanut butter cups that taste like stale chemicals. These taste fresh and have the texture of real food. The ingredients are so much better quality too!

Back around Halloween, I saw that there was an organic Reese’s and Hershey bars. Intrigued, I bought both. Despite I was never a peanut butter cup fan, I discovered I preferred the Reese’s. They’re good. Last week, I wanted to order more—I’ll buy three boxes at a time—but they had only one box left. I bought it, but I wanted more than one box. I’ve lost a lot of weight so I eat two packs a day as a treat but to also try to gain the weight back. I saw Justin’s organic peanut butter cups and although they are pricier, I bought one box until they have more Reese’s in stock. HOWEVER, once I tasted Justin’s, it was over. Sorry but I don’t believe I’ll be buying Reese’s again. This is phenomenal. Seriously, the chocolate is so rich, the peanut butter tastes the way homemade peanut butter tastes, the kind where the oil rises and you have to stir it. I cannot believe how good these are. So I decided to set up subscribe & save for delivery every two weeks. Seriously, treat yourself to something fantastic. This! !

They are really good and rich. Nice flavor, the milk chocolate is better than the dark.

These are the most amazing peanut-butter cups I’ve ever had. The chocolate melts fast, though, so, in hot climates you would need to refrigerate them. The first ones I ate last night were melted & yummy but messy. Packing them in ice would’ve helped. Our spring temps here have varied from 40-80. For me, the best thing was I could eat them, at all. I have an allergic to TBHQ, the preservative in Reese’s, so these are a godsend, since PB cups are my favorite candy. They are definitely yummy, have a good texture (smooth), are an excellent value for the money, and don’t make my eyes swell up or ears plug. Yay!

If I had never tried a store-bought package of Justin's cups before, these would probably have five stars. Sadly, they are really different from when I buy them at Whole Foods. The taste is similar, but the size and texture are very different. The peanut butter is definitely more dry...not chalky/inedible, but not creamy like when you get them from the store. They are noticeably thinner and the rippled edges they usually have are non-existent. They are more like chocolate covered peanut butter circles than the peanut butter cups we've come to know and love. I'm wondering if the boxes being sold on amazon are faulty batches or something, especially with the cheaper price. All in all, they're fine, but worth the extra .50 to buy in store.

I bought these thinking they were vegan... they aren't. They are organic though. They are very tasty. I ate like half of them in one sitting. They are a good treat for cheat day or if you want to make something special like a dessert or something. They are expensive but worth it. I like them better than Reese's! The chocolate and peanut butter taste good. They weren't melted or anything ( separated) but it is still May. I'd have to see how they are in the summer months. I put them in the refrigerator after I got them in case they were melted.

So yummy. It is a nice treat.

I have been buying this product in the store like Whole Foods and it is fabulous!! To get more quantity I purchased this on Amazon and was very disappointed because obviously they don’t know how to ship it chocolate to keep it fresh. The order just was not fresh where when I pick this up in the store, the peanut butter is nice and creamy and the peanut butter was not From Amazon and you can tell the chocolate melted a bit. This would have 0 stars but you have to put something.