Milani Mascara Volume and Length, Highly Rated Anti-Gravity Black Shade with Castor Oil and Molded Hourglass Shaped Lash Coating Mascara Wand

I wanted to try out tubing mascara so bad and didn’t wanna spent a ton of money on one tubing mascara that I might not like, so I bought this one and the elf lash XRndr mascara that’s also a more budget friendly tubing mascara. Out of the two, this is my new # one mascara that I’m gonna use. I mostly love how buildable it is and by buildable I mean, it doesn’t dry very fast allowing multiple coats and I can create dramatic full & beautiful long lashes by double coating it on or a less dramatic more natural look with a few swipes and it separates my lashes very well, too. This mascara also doesn’t smudge or flake and lasts. The only con at all would be that because it’s a tubing mascara, it’s more difficult to remove over regular mascaras. To remove I use an oil based facial cleanser and warm water and comes off, no problem. I absolutely love this mascara and will recommend it and continue to buy!

I literally gave up wearing mascara for almost a year. Regardless of the brand, within 30 minutes of applying, I had black circles under my eyes. It was a nightmare. I tried Panda Eyes. That was a bust. I've been wearing CLIO Kill Lash. It doesn't give me black circles, but I don't love the formula. It's quite dry, and the tube doesn't last very long. But THIS! Not THE best mascara I've EVER worn, but definitely a game changer for those who struggle with black circles. I even left it on overnight to see what would happen by morning. STILL ZERO smudging. And...it comes off SO easily in the shower. (The Kill Lash was a nightmare to remove.) This is the first mascara in years that I actually look forward to putting on even on days where I otherwise wouldn't likely apply make-up.

First let me say that this is good for the price! I was looking for a Thrive mascara dupe and this works for 1/3 of the price. I will say Thrive is still better of the two, but this one stays on better than thrive! I don’t like the way this one goes on initially; it’s almost too thin and it puts too much product on my eyelash and takes a couple of minutes to even back out with a separate tool.So they both have their pros and cons. But if you’re looking for a price saving dupe, this is it!

This is the best mascara that I have every used. It goes on smoothly, needs only one or two coats to have long, thick, totally separated lashes, with NO clumps, doesn't run if my eyes water for some reason, and I will use only this mascara from now on. The price is fantastic too!

THIS IS BY FAR THE BEST MASCARA ON THE MARKET! It is tubing so it’s super easy to stay on but it also doesn’t flake and can last for over 24 hours. Helps hold my lash curl

Im asian with straight / boneless lashesI like the idea of this tubing mascara because it doesnt smear and is pretty easy to remove at the end of the day. However, my lashes wont hold a curl with this mascara. It seems once i use the lash curler after mascara application, it removes some of the mascara and also straightens out again. Same goes for when i use the curler before applying, it just straightens back out. Typically other mascaras, my curl can hold quite well. If i layer too much of this mascara, it almost looks like i have spider leg lashes. So thats not too cute. Im gonna try to see if i can make the consistency more tacky and see if thatll make a difference

The media could not be loaded. I went on a mission to find the best tubing mascara by testing three highly-rated but budget-friendly options. Here’s how they stacked up:🥉 3rd Place – SHEGLAM: Not bad, but I had to layer on more coats than I’d like to get noticeable results. That said, it’s a compact tube, which makes it perfect for my purse. Great for quick touch-ups when I just need a little lash boost on the go.🥈 2nd Place – MILANI: Solid mascara! It gives decent volume and definition, and I definitely reach for it. But when it comes to bold drama...🥇 1st Place – Bye Bye Panda Eyes: Total game changer! Bold, dramatic lashes without the raccoon smudge. No flakes, no under-eye mess, and it washes off like a dream. This one stole my heart (and my lashes).If you’re curious about tubing mascaras, they’re a must if you hate the dreaded end-of-day panda look. Clean, lightweight, and eye-brightening magic.

I use this as a thrive causemetics dupe. It's the closest thing I've found to being comparable. Seller sent as requested and were on sale when I ordered!