PlayVital 10-Pack Pro Thumb Grips for Xbox Series X/S, One/Elite | Ergonomic FPS Joystick Caps, 3 Height Convex & Concave | for ps5, Edge, Switch 2 Pro Controller | Raised Dots & Studded Design, Black

I've literally only just tested applying them (I only have 3rd party controllers, so I wanted to make sure they'd even work --- FWIW: I tried them on a Flydigi Vader stick (they all use the same sticks), a Gamesir T4K (I *think* Gamesir sticks all have the same domes), and a Thunderobot G50S). As many other reviewers have said, they CAN be very tricky to get on, but once I realized exactly how I was supposed to bend it back, it was then easy to pop them on & have it close around the dome of the stick. This may be uncommon, but personally I notice when I move an analog stick around (especially at full extension in any direction), I tend to actually push it from the edge of the dome in the direction I want it to go (as opposed to putting my thumb on the top of the stick & directing it with the tip of my thumb). Maybe I'm just not precise with my control, lol. That's where the "so far" comes in, because during testing I found that if I put enough pressure on it from the side, it slipped off VERY easily (though, while moving it by touching the top, it was fine. I should also specify that this was from the literal side of the tall-cap. Putting my thumb on the edge of the rim, "pushing" down & in the direction I wanted, I could get fairly wild with the stick and it would be fine). Now, I acknowledge testing a controller without a game often results in more aggressive movements that you might not actually achieve during gameplay. (Also, I should note that it stayed on best with the Gamesir, which has the roughest texture along the rim of the dome, of my 3 controllers). I'll also say I went with the Quantum Black. Both because they claimed to be more matte, and because I was unsure of what texture pattern I'd like best, and these ones (at least the 4 concave caps) have a "very similar" pattern to the best seller offered by who is probably the industry leader in thumbstick caps (& if that many people like galaxy, it's probably good - honestly, that was the deciding factor between these & some from a reptilian competitor). What I liked though, was that these PlayVital ones are (allegedly) universal, and it gave many options for size & concave/convex. For someone like me who is new to using them, I wasn't sure what height or shape I'd like best (meanwhile I'd have to have paid $4 more for only 2 caps, usually 2 different sizes (so I can't leave them on multiple controllers), from the other provider). Especially because while I thought "hell yea, get that aiming stick as tall as possible!!", after the brief testing, I wouldn't be shocked if that's too tall (for an extended period of play), for my shorter fingers (which could also explain why I do the rim-pushing method sometimes), and I wind up using the medium instead. Overall, I'd say this is a very good buy & I'd recommend them for anyone who is new to thumbstick caps.

Was good

Great Grip but a hassle to put on the controller

Five stars of perfection.

These things are great for PS5 controller. I put the biggest ones on mine. They do feel weird at first but give it a day or so and you will get use to the change. They haven’t fallen off once. Would highly recommended if you are on the fence.

Very hard to get on . But once on they are great

They fit tightly and stay on. Great option to extend the joysticks

You need to master the super secret GFL technique to get these on, good freaking luck. Literally every review you see about these being hard to get on and not worth the struggle and fears of breaking the controller is 1000% accurate. "Designed by gamers for a gamers." What a joke. 40 minutes and i somehow got one of them on. Don't buy.