iDesign 21700 Basic Shower Tray without Drilling, Long Bath Shelf, Made of Sturdy Plastic with Suction Cups, Clear

I love the idea of these. The clear keeps the shower area fresh and clean looking. Easy to clean. The different sizes are ideal. However, every few days these just fall down. We have the smallest size with one toothbrush and one half used tube of toothpaste inside, another with one razor in it, and they both will not stay suctioned to the completely flat surface of our shower no matter how accurate we are to follow instructions on how to apply. We've even suctioned it so that the bottom of the caddy sat on the small moulded shelf in the shower unit for support and it will still fall even when nobody is in the room, hours after bathroom use, in middle of the night, all random times. If the suction cups were ultra strong and designed to work perfectly for long periods of time I'd give them a 5-Star.

When we first got this I kind of laughed at the suction cups because when I put them on the wall of our coach showered the outer edges did not suction on just the inner parts. But for two months it has been hanging on with some pretty large items in it and a VERY large and heavy block of pre de Provence bar of soap in it and it has not fallen off yet even with us traveling, very impressed! I gave it five stars! Don’t hesitate, it’s a good one.

It'll never rust...This is my second one of these. I had the last one for about 4 years and it worked very well and had plenty of room to keep my stuff.However, that one crashed to the ground in the middle of the night. (scared the bejeezus outta me!)Because this thing is made of a nice, sturdy, yet brittle plastic, it didn't fare well from a 6 foot free fall onto the ceramic tile floor. Yes, I keep mine mounted that high... and it was fully loaded too.I don't blame the failure on the product because I think its good practice to un-mount every once-in-a-while anything that is held in place with suction cups. Obviously I missed a round of routine maintenance.The other thing I'll share, and no, I don't think this contributed to it's failure... Because I mount this thing on ceramic tiles which measure just over 4 inches square, I retro-fitted the suction cups by removing the two middle ones then drilled a hole directly into the center of those two holes (center mass) then plugged one of the suckers back in. Viola... It now attaches nicely and securely with 3 suckers. Without doing this it will only grab with the cups on each end.Hope this helps, please click if it does.

I’m a bit disappointed with this tray. First off the four suction cups are not in any way affixed to the tray so it makes securing it a little bit of a challenge because they keep falling out. Second it only has two drainage holes, one in each front corner so it holds water and doesn’t drain very well unless you angle it funny which prevents you from standing up anything. Third I’ve had this tray for five days now in my shower and I’ve had to reattach it almost every day because it’s fallen off along with everything (toothpaste and a little face scrub sponge). For the price I expected more.

This is a nice corner soapdish with great suction except that it suctioned super hard, almost unremovable, on some surfaces and barely stuck to others. Kind of strange but it’s a nice little shelf. Suction cups fell right out if you took it off which was weird. If you have a solid surface to mount them to with the suction cups, they are very effective and it’s a nice shelf.