e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner, Creamy, Ultra-Pigmented & Waterproof, Creates Bold & Defined Lines, Vegan & Cruelty-Free, Grey

I don't wear a lot of makeup as it, and I wanted to add something that matched my natural dark brown features. This eyeliner is fantastic, easily applies to your skin and it's easy to take off with makeup wipes. I've had no issue with it smudging on my eyes, as it's stayed in place all day when it comes to moving around and manual labor. It is waterproof, that's true! And it stays on for at least 7 hours. You can touch it up and it looks great when re-applying. I'm going to buy this eyeliner again, especially knowing this was the first time I've bought an Elf branded product before!

Everything else makes lines above my eyelids within an hour. This stuff stays where it should. It may wear off a little on my lower lids, but then I reapply. And when it wears off, it seems to just disappear—not transfer to other parts of my body.

Pro: I like the brown color, softness and it glides well with the sharp point along the eye line on both upper and lower lashes. I was careful to let it set for 30 seconds so it wouldn't smudge, and it lasted all day for me. I didn't remove it with anything, just washed my face with tepid water and in the morning nothing was on my silk pillowcase so that was fine with me. I can't comment on how waterproof it is, but it has great smudge resistance once set.Con: I've only used it once, so I have no idea how long it will last yet. It doesn't have a built-in sharpener and crayon is quite thin so I'm not giving it 5 stars until I've had it long enough. If Amazon allows an update, I'll do a followup review.

I am quite pleased with this eyeliner. The product, itself, went on very easily. It had almost a silky feeling as I applied it to both top and bottom lids. The black color is rich. The retractable dispenser is easy to use.

The gray shade is perfect for my greenish/ gray eyes. I've used black in the past but to me, my eyes then scream "Hi!! I'm wearing black eyeliner!!" ;-) Maybe it's my age, but I prefer something more subtle, and this fits the bill: flattering as opposed to attention-grabbing.

This isn't bad, but I am slightly disappointed; my eye liner pencil was new and not damaged. I found it a bit dry and, although it said it could be used on the waterline, I find it dry, thick and slightly uncomfortable on my sensitive eyes. It doesn't run or flake, the colour is as expected. I do use it, but if I had a pencil with a finer tip and a nicer feel, I would throw this away. Mine might be a bit old, by some fluke, and my eyes are probably more sensitive than average. This pencil could work very well for some, especially people who want a thicker line along the external lash line (although don't expect to blend it out a lot). It is doing the job when I absolutely need something, though. I was just hoping for a slightly different formula.

This is my favorite eyeliner. Not too thick. Not too thin. Goes on beautifully. Love the charcoal gray color. Priced better than the competitors, too, but doesn’t break like the “other” brands!

I can’t say enough good things about this eyeliner! It stays sharp, lasts forever and is a great price!!