CLIO Superproof Pen Liquid Eyeliner, Waterproof Smudge Proof Long Wear, Ultra Precision Sponge Tip, One Stroke High Pigment Color, Fast Dry Formula, Sharp Wing, Safe for Sensitive Eyes (001 Black)

Easy to draw a fine line. Cheaper than other brands I’ve used in past. Haven gone in water to test waterproofing but has lasted all day.

Hands down, this beats so many luxury department store brand eyeliners. It has good staying power in the water line, just make sure you fan it dry after applying. It should stay put for a few hours.

Very fine line. Doesn’t smudge. Cones off easy with make up remover pad.

I’d read a lot about this and am always on the hunt for the perfect stay-all-day eyeliner. This one is okay. I still felt like it did not last through the whole day. Application is easy, the line is nicely thin and easy to give a little flick at the end. It did not smudge on the top, but did have some transfer below my eyes. I have better luck with the dip / brush NYX epic wear, but would love to find a felt tip eye liner that stays as well.

I've been using this eyeliner for about two weeks, and it has been great. The product matches its description well. I really like the tip of the liner - it's easy to use and precise. It doesn't smudge under my eyes, doesn't melt off, and lasts a long time.

Not long lasting for the entire day. The colors come off throughout the day, so it ends up looks blotchy. No raccoon eyes tho!

My favorite eye liner. Smudged free and long lasting. Easy to apply as well. The formula is great. Very affordable too.

Very disappointed 😩. I use this company's mascara and it's really waterproof, so I decided to try this company's eyeliner, and I'm very disappointed😢. It's not waterproof and doesn't stay on without water, so it's not worth the money, and I also bought two black and brown eyeliner, which was a waste of money.

プロのメイクさんも使用していて おすすめしてくれました 今までで1番使いやすくずっと これに決めました

Was SUPER excited to try this eyeliner. With all the 5 star reviews, eyeliner is OVERHYPED. NOT WATERPROOF AT ALL. Don't buy if you think it'll last all day. I drew a few strokes on my hand and just with WATER on a cotton pad. The eyeliner came right off.

乾燥目元に書きやすいしコスパ良いと思います

I've tried at least 30 different eyeliners (despite many recommendations and buying from the cheapest to most expensive and none really performed) and this is the first with no transfer or budging and I'm so pleased. (thanks jennytwong on You Tube)

I used from this May , but it’s really excellent. I recommend this eye liner.