Grumpy Butcher Aged New York Strip Steaks, 8 Pack - USDA Top Choice Beef Steak With Gift Box Option - Ships Frozen

It was a total impulse buy, but I’m so glad I went for it! Arrived the next day, well packed to stay cold.. I thawed one for dinner and cooked it in a hot skillet with olive oil, using my seasoning. 5 min on one side, 3 on the other and got a perfect crust. Let it rest for a minute, then we split it after a quick discussion on who got which half. It was just perfect. Tender, buttery and full of flavor, just like a high quality NY Strip. We had it with roasted vegetables and a big pot of herbed, buttered mashed potatoes. Honestly, I shouldn’t have second-guessed this purchase. Everything about it was excellent, and I’ll definitely be ordering more!

So worth the buy. Excellent knives, sharp and they do a very good job at cutting my meat. We buy beef in bulk and slice our own steaks & such. These knives do the trick. They do a great job at slicing.

All the “prime” steaks from this box are the worst example of prime I have ever seen. Not worth the cost at all to have this delivered. Almost 0 marbling in each of these cuts. 10/10 will never purchase from Grumpy Butcher again.

Bought these for my Dad for Christmas. When I asked if he had tried one, he said yes but wasn’t going to say anything because the meat was tough and was of poor quality. So we have a grumpy customer for the Grumpy Butcher.

I ordered 8 strip steaks. The meat was more tender than filet mignon, very fresh, lightning fast shipping and at a decent price. One or two minor gripes tho - they came packaged 4 steaks to a package partially frozen while I prefer individually wrapped steaks. Also, one package of 4 steaks appeared to be a tangled mess of cut meat rather than "steak" steaks. It's still delicious but if I saw the presentation in local butcher shop I would have passed it by.

Bought these Grumpy Butcher strip steaks for a weekend dinner and seared them in a cast iron skillet—3 minutes per side, then rested for a few. The marbling was spot on, and they stayed tender even cooked to medium, which my wife prefers. Our neighbor popped by for a drink and ended up finishing a steak too—he couldn’t stop raving. Only nitpick: I wish the thickness was a bit more consistent across the pack to allow for universall doness, but flavor and quality were definitely there.

They were good. They had a different taste and texture than we have ever tasted. Don't think I'll ever buy again .

Got this collection as a holiday present. It was all about that soothing, enveloping flavor🔥