Revlon ColorStay Liquid Eye Pen Classic

This was my first liquid eyeliner purchase and I love it! I've always used the Revlon ColorStay pencil, but after using this, I will not go back. It's super easy to use and the quality is great. It doesn't smudge and stays on until I take it off. The pen is strong & durable with a pull-off tip/lid. The pen/tip goes on thin, fine, and smooth yet dries quickly once applied to the eyelid. I love it!

Love this! Applies easily and gives a perfect wing look. It lasts all day and doesn’t smudge, even when I apply eye drops multiple times. Definitely waterproof but it comes off easily with makeup remover and a cotton swab. I’ve learned if you hold a dampened cotton swab with makeup remover on for a few seconds and then wipe across your eyes, it comes off really easily.

I’ve tried a lot of liquid eyeliners, and the Revlon Liquid Eyeliner Pen is definitely one of my favorites. The felt tip is just the right firmness—it glides on easily and makes it super simple to create a sharp wing or a subtle line. The pigment is rich and dark, and it dries quickly without smudging. What really impressed me is the staying power—it lasts all day without fading or flaking, even through heat and humidity. Plus, it’s easy to remove with makeup wipes or micellar water. Great quality at a reasonable price. Definitely a staple in my makeup bag!

Goes on easily, but does not stay on for very long. The eyeliner in the middle of my eyes stay on for most of the day. The eyeliner on the ends of my eyes wears off within a few hours. JMO - everyone's eyes are different. What doesn't work for me may work for you. For the price point, it's worth a try.

I've been using the Revlon Liquid Eyeliner Pen, ColorStay Sharp Line for a long time, and it never disappoints! The color is deep and rich, giving my eyes a bold, defined look without needing to press hard on my eyelid. The slim, tapered tip makes it easy to create a sharp, clean line every time — whether I’m going for a subtle look or a more dramatic wing. It's truly waterproof and smudge-proof, staying perfect all day without fading or smearing. Plus, the price is fantastic for the quality you get. I always repurchase this eyeliner and highly recommend it to anyone looking for a reliable, long-wearing option!

This is my go to liquid liner. It’s so easy to use and lasts a while. I like that it’s so black just like it says it’s supposed to look. It hasn’t caused me any irritations and it doesn’t smudge. It does take a bit to wash off as water alone doesn’t do the trick. But that’s totally fine.

This applies really well, even with my slightly older, starting to wrinkle, fine skin. It is my favorite of the many eyeliners I have tried in terms of how smoothly it applies. The pigmentation is nice a dark and smooth. However, I took off a few stars because it wears off for me in a few hours. It is not very smudge resistant.

Never smudges, runs, flakes off or irritates my eyes. Very easy to apply. Provides a smooth, even application. You can create a thin or thicker line. I make a thin line at the inner corner and gradually make it thicker towards the outer edge of my eye. Rich black color. Stays on until you take it off. Removes easily with Garnier micellar cleansing water or Neutrogena Fresh Foaming Cleanser. I’ve been using this eyeliner for years. I would never change. The pen lasts a really long time. The tip is very durable. It doesn’t lose its shape or anything for the life of the product. This eyeliner will equal or beat any expensive department store brand. It’s a steal at this price!