MK Kelpie Low D Whistle – Non-Tunable Aluminum Musical Low Whistle for beginners, intermediate, and Professional players/musicians (Anodized Black)

My favorite whistle in my collection. There was a learning curve for sure as it is quite a reach but don't get discouraged. I have small hands and after some practice you can get it with pipers grip. Lovely sound and right in tune

I do enjoy this whistle. It has a great sound, very little maintenance, and plays well with other instruments. The holes are dynamic without being too big for your fingers in a paper's grip. I'll get the MK Pro next time for the tuning slide, but I do love the Kelpie.

I bought this whistle soon after learning the high whistle. Because of some mailing issues, I ended up with a Howard Whistle at the same time. The Kelpie has a breathier, haunting sound, while the Howard has a clearer, more flute-like sound. The Kelpie is heavier and all metal, so it may be safer on a camping trip. I think it's a tad easier to play because the holes are slightly smaller and easier to cover, especially since I'm using a piper's grip on the far end (D, E, and F). I can reach the holes with my finger tips, but it's harder to land quickly. The wool pouch is very nice and will likely outlast the plastic sleeve the Howard is packed in. Now there's nothing wrong with a Howard Whistle. Both of these are fine instruments. It's a matter of taste and overall preference. I'd suggest finding some video demonstrations, such as the Cutie Pie videos.

Having enjoyed playing woodwinds since my youth, whistles have been a simple joy to me. Amongst a collection of Celtic flutes and various woodwinds, a few whistles in various keys have always been a constant go to for portable entertainment. Having been somewhat partial to my old high D whistle, I desired to be able to enjoy this same feel and style of play, but with the deep richness of my low D Celtic flute. I received my MK Selkie in low D recently after a bit of research. It did not disappoint. The finish was nice. It was tuned spot on. The mouthpiece is comfortable and hasn’t clogged. It has a good deal of back pressure, which is great as a larger volume of air is required for larger woodwinds. I have large hands, so the holes, though a further stretch, can be accessed by me with or without a piper’s grip with my lower hand. Once.warmed up, the resonance of this whistle has a deep, far away sound, yet not too airy. It is a heavier and well made whistle. It’s great for trad play and anything that sounds good with a deep low sound. I regret not buying it sooner. I highly recommend it for those who play alone. The tunable model might be preferable for group sessions, though, as an option.

This is my first professional level whistle. It was packed really well and came without a scratch. It is heavy and well made. The sound is beautiful. I checked the notes and they were spot on. Yes it is well worth the money. That said, please note the size of the instrument. If you have small to medium hands you will likely struggle to play it. Also if you are a beginner you may find that it has a learning curve.

This whistle has a really nice sound to it, my music vocabulary isn't the most impressive yet, but it has a haunting, breathy sound to it. The upper register is really responsive too, you do have to put some strong pressure in to hit that high B and A, but it sounds nice in both octaves. I've seen people play it with the first pads of their fingers, maybe with some stretching I could get there, but I find a pipers grip on F, E, and D to be more comfortable. It's a very nice looking whistle. One solid black piece, a nice finish, with a little brightly polished ring on the inside which you can see through the top whistle/hole bit. I imagine this thing will outlast me barring some sort of catastrophic event, or someone purposefully destroying it.

Out of tune, had to send back. (Edit) I recived a replacement instrument and it sounded fine.

I am absolutely in love with this thing! The tone, and the matte anodized texture are perfect! I also like the mouthpiece shape—it’s very comfortable. The tone is hard to describe: sweet, but with some chiff. Whistles that get uncomfortably shrill really hurt my ears. Of course, as a low whistle it’s not likely to be shrill, however this has convinced me to try the MK Midgie because the tone is so amazing! It’s not tunable, which is the only con. I have small hands, and had no trouble using pipers grip. I am going to save my pennies for another from MK. For me, there is no point to look elsewhere.