SEPHORA COLLECTION Contour Eye Pencil.

My mom says this stays on good and is better than the knock-off brands. She does have a harder time removing it at the end of the day (of course), and she needed to keep sharpening it (she has a sharpener) but it is a great alternative for her than the the more expensive stuff. I know nothing of make-up stuff but I do understand saving money and still getting the job done.

So most eyeliner say that they’re smudge proof & they’re not however and waterproof, but their not however this one REALLY isBB HAPPY TO SAY IT LASTED 10.5 hr shift!

I will reorder other colors. Easy to use and sharpens easily and doesn’t crumble. Good color saturation.

I like the way it goes on smoothly the first time. I don’t have to keep coloring the same line over and over to get it to mark.

This expensive pencil is too soft. The whole tip broke off the very first time I used it and then it wouldn't advance when I twisted the bottom. (I tried twisting the top too, nothing worked.) This is a plastic pencil, not a wooden one where the tip can be sharpened. I returned the first pencil and was sent a replacement... and the same thing happened again. I was able to use the replacement two times though before the tip broke completely off and then wouldn't advance. When I tried to replace the second pencil, the return site wouldn't let me. It just kept saying a replacement had already been sent. I gave 2 stars instead of 1, because the two times I wore this it didn't smudge.